Adding insult to injury

Nancy Churchill, a writer and educator in rural eastern Washington State, and the state committeewoman for the Ferry County Republican Party wrote an article posted in Clark County Today News, that “Questions the superfund declaration for beautiful Lake Roosevelt.” Click here to read the article.

Full of innaccurate information, the article is irresponsible reporting that spreads misinformation, trivializes the destruction of both the environment and residents’ health, and adds insult to an already heartbreaking situation. Below is my comment to her post, which was later deleted.


Response to “The Biden EPA is Divorced from Reality” article:

Dear Mrs, Churchill,

Your article demonstrates a troubling lack of research and understanding of the situation in Northport.

Your claim of only nine residential cleanups is blatantly false. There have been 59 residential cleanups in Northport, and many more still require remediation. The testing that resulted in these cleanups comfirmed that heavy metal toxins in these areas originated from air emissions released by Teck Smelter. The Leroi smelter, which operated briefly in the early 1900s, contributed contamination only in limited areas like the city park and waterfront.

Despite Northport’s small population of just 300 residents, multiple generations have suffered from rare autoimmune diseases linked to this contamination, devastating their quality of life.

Your statement that “…an agreement to address the pollution and perform remediation has been in place for more than 20 years! Much remediation already happened without any Superfund designation.” is inaccurate and completely ignores the 25+ year battle fought by the Colville Confederated Tribes, the State of Washington, the EPA, Ecology, and grassroots advocates to hold Teck accountable. While Teck agreed to conduct a remedial investigation and feasibility study (RI/FS) in 2006, they spent the next 18 years delaying progress with flawed studies and repeatedly appealing court rulings that held them responsible for dumping millions of tons of toxic waste into the Upper Columbia River. These tactics stalled efforts to address the dangerously high levels of heavy metal toxins in the region. With no accountability or action from Teck, the EPA had no choice but to propose listing the site on the Superfund National Priorities List (NPL) to secure funding and protect public health and the environment.

I urge you to consult reliable sources, such as The Northport Project, Citizens for a Clean Columbia, Lake Roosevelt Forum, and the EPA and Ecology’s websites, which detail investigations, sampling, and research results.

Finally, your conclusion that “This “Superfund” is a way to funnel taxpayer money into “research” to “find” more pollution. The EPA is just going to ignore that nature appears to be doing pretty well out here without much human interference.” is not only inaccurate but extremely insulting considering the well documented destruction Teck’s actions have caused to our environment and the health of generations of residents.

I recommend you read “The Death List” on The Northport Project site to grasp the actual reality of the situation, which is the devastating health impacts Teck’s gross negligence has created. Our reality is suffering from these health issues, and watching loved ones suffer as well.

The only one who seems to be divorced from the reality of the situation is you.

Shame on you for your irresponsible reporting of misinformation on a situation you clearly know nothing about. Do better.

Jamie Paparich – The Northport Project NorthportProject@hotmail.com


Nancy Churchill may be reached at DangerousRhetoric@pm.me. Share your thoughts with her on her article.

Leave a Reply

Up ↑